Imitation or Reality?

Mistaking the model for reality is an error that is easy to make, often because the model matches our preconceptions rather than the actual features being modeled. And we like to believe our preconceptions are correct–after all, preconceptions are much easier and faster than a rigorous analysis in search of reality. This tale from Aesop’s Fables illustrates the problem and urges us to be mindful of  pre-existing contexts that may be influencing our investigations:

A rich nobleman once opened the theaters without charge to the people, and gave a public notice that he would handsomely reward any person who invented a new amusement for the occasion.

Various public performers contended for the prize. Among them came a jester well known among the populace for his jokes, and said that he had a kind of entertainment that had never been brought out on any stage before. This report being spread about made a great stir, and the theater was crowded in every part.
The jester appeared alone upon the platform, without any apparatus or confederates, and the very sense of expectation caused an intense silence. He suddenly bent his head towards his bosom and imitated the squeaking of a little pig so admirably with his voice that the audience declared he had a porker under his cloak and demanded that it should be shaken out. When that was done and nothing was found, they cheered the actor, and loaded him with the loudest applause.

A countryman in the crowd, observing all that had passed, said, “So help me, Hercules, he shall not beat me at that trick!” and at once proclaimed that he would do the same thing on the next day, though in a much more natural way.

On the next day an even larger crowd assembled in the theater, but now partiality for their favorite actor very generally prevailed, and the audience came rather to ridicule the countryman than to see the spectacle.

Both of the performers appeared on the stage. The jester grunted and squeaked away first, and obtained, as on the preceding day, the applause and cheers of the spectators.

Next the countryman commenced, and pretending that he concealed a little pig beneath his clothes—which in truth he did, but not suspected by the audience—he contrived to take hold of and to pull its ear causing the pig to squeak.

The crowd, however, cried out with one consent that the jester had given a far more exact imitation, and clamored for the countryman to be kicked out of the theater.
On this, the rustic produced the little pig from his cloak and showed by the most positive proof the greatness of their mistake.

“Look here,” he said, “this shows what sort of judges you are.”

A wise man, observing all that happened, remarked, “People often applaud an imitation and hiss the real thing.”

—Aesop

What is the pre-existing context and what are the preconceptions in this tale?

Author: Craig Butcher

Craig Butcher is an award-winning educator who has taught critical thinking skills for more than two decades. In addition, He has worked on Capitol Hill as a congressional aide and has been a top-rated broadcaster.